A South African town is divided over changing its name from the colonial-era Graaff-Reinet to Robert Sobukwe, after the anti-apartheid activist, in a debate that has inflamed racial tensions.
Petitions have been signed, rival marches held and a formal letter of complaint sent to the sports, arts and culture minister, Gayton McKenzie, who approved the name change on 6 February.
On one side are people who feel a deep attachment to Graaff-Reinet, many regardless of the fact it was named after Cornelis Jacob van de Graaff, the Dutch governor of the Cape Colony when the town was founded in 1786, and his wife, Hester Cornelia Reynet.
On the other are those who insist that renaming the town after Sobukwe, who was born and buried there, is a necessary part of the “transformation” of South Africa away from colonialism and white-minority apartheid rule.
Sobukwe left the African National Congress (ANC) liberation movement to found the Pan Africanist Congress in 1959, amid disagreements about the ANC allowing white members. On 21 March 1960, Sobukwe led protests against laws requiring Black people to carry pass books. Police opened fire on a march, killing 69 people in what became known as the Sharpeville massacre.
Between 2000 and 2024, more than 1,500 placenames were changed in South Africa, according to an official database. They include more than 400 post offices, 144 rivers and seven airports, while the city of Port Elizabeth became Gqeberha in 2021.
The department of sports, arts and culture said in a statement announcing 21 name changes, including Graaff-Reinet: “The mission … [is] to redress, correct and transform the geographical naming system in order to advance restorative justice, including addressing the colonial and apartheid-era naming legacy.”
A survey carried out in December 2023 found 83.6% of the town’s residents opposed the name change, including 92.9% of Coloured people, 98.5% of white people and 55% of Black people. A third of Black residents backed the change. Of the 367 randomly selected representative respondents, 54% were Coloured, 27.2% Black and 18.8% white.
“Many residents felt that changing the name would erase part of their identity as ‘Graaff-Reinetters’,” the Stellenbosch University geography professor Ronnie Donaldson wrote of his findings.
Laughton Hoffman, who runs a non-profit supporting young people, expressed concern about the name change harming tourism in the town, which has a population of about 51,000 and whose centre is filled with elegant, whitewashed Cape Dutch buildings.
“We are not emotional about the Dutch … Out of the grief of the past [the name Graaff-Reinet] became a benefit for the people and for the economy of the town,” said Hoffman, sporting a bright pink “Hands Off Graaff-Reinet” T-shirt.
Hoffman is Coloured and Khoi-San – indigenous South Africans who the apartheid government lumped together as Coloured with mixed-race people and the descendants of enslaved people from other parts of Africa, Indonesia and Malaysia.
Hoffman said his community had been “oppressed” since the end of apartheid by governments led by the black-dominated ANC. “We have been marginalised for 32 years as a cultural group,” he said.
Coloured researchers attribute much of this resentment felt by parts of their community to animosity between Coloured and Black communities fostered by apartheid. Coloured people were allowed slightly better houses and jobs, forcing them to distance themselves from Black people to access those benefits.
Meanwhile, Derek Light, a lawyer who wrote the complaint letter demanding that the culture minister McKenzie reverse his decision, argued that the public consultation on the name change did not follow legal procedure. “It was a faux process,” he said.
Light, who is white, lamented the tensions the name change had caused in the town. “We were living in peace and harmony,” he said. “It’s not without fault; we also have poverty and unemployment and things like that. But we don’t have racial issues amongst our people.”
Black members of the Robert Sobukwe Steering Committee, a group supporting the name change, rejected this. “We have always had racial problems,” said Athe Singeni. “It was very subtle.”
Her mother, Nomandla, said they would not be deterred, even after Sobukwe’s grave was vandalised by unknown people earlier this month. “We as Black people, we have a history that has been erased,” she said. “We’ve got leaders who contributed and laid down their lives for the freedom that we enjoy today. It is time to honour them.”
Further up the hill in uMasizakhe, a former Black township, a group enjoying home-brewed alcohol expressed their support for the name change. “I’m happy to change this name, Graaff-Reinet,” said Mzoxolo Nkhomo, a 59-year-old jobseeker. “Because Sobukwe is our fighter. Sobukwe made us free.”
Across the road, the Robert Mangaliso Sobukwe Museum and Learning Centre was shuttered, a statue of the politician covered up. It had never been officially opened due to family disagreements, said his grandson Mangaliso Tsepo Sobukwe.
Placename changes had been instrumentalised by politicians, Sobukwe said. “It is interesting that the ANC would be seen championing the honouring of Sobukwe, because they … [have been] suppressing his legacy.”
Sobukwe expected the backlash to the renaming, but added: “Going forward, I’m happy that my grandfather’s been honoured, more than anything else.”
