The Signal 24हिंदी

Is there a creamy layer for SCs and STs?

Not in jobs or admissions today. The creamy-layer exclusion applies to OBCs. In the 2024 sub-classification judgment four Supreme Court judges said states should evolve a creamy-layer policy for SCs and STs, but that was not the court’s binding holding, and on 9 August 2024 the Union Cabinet said the Constitution has no provision for one. In the promotions case, Jarnail Singh (2018), the court said the creamy-layer principle can be applied to SCs and STs; no such rule has been notified.

The hard truth

The debate is loud and the data is missing: no government publishes how the SC and ST quotas are actually shared within those lists, which is the one fact that would show whether the benefit is concentrated.

What the law actually says

The creamy-layer exclusion comes from Indra Sawhney (1992), which applied it to the backward classes, and the Department of Personnel and Training’s rules apply it to OBCs only. In Jarnail Singh v Lachhmi Narain Gupta (2018) a Constitution Bench, reviewing M. Nagaraj on reservation in promotions, said the principle of excluding the creamy layer can be applied to SCs and STs. In State of Punjab v Davinder Singh (2024) four of the seven judges said states should develop a policy to identify a creamy layer among SCs and STs; the majority’s holding was about sub-classification. No central or state rule currently excludes a creamy layer from SC or ST reservation in recruitment or admission.

What you can do

  1. Read what the judgments actually held, not commentary: Davinder Singh (2024) and Jarnail Singh (2018).
  2. Check your recruitment notice: if it does not ask SC or ST candidates for a non-creamy-layer certificate, none is required.
  3. Watch for any notification by the Union or your state government; only that would change the rule.
  4. Ask under RTI for community-wise data on SC and ST appointments if you want to test the argument.

Where people get caught out

  • Being asked for a non-creamy-layer certificate as an SC or ST candidate. Unless a notified rule requires it, it does not apply.
  • Treating judges’ observations as law. Only the holding binds; the 2024 creamy-layer remarks were not it.
  • Confusing sub-classification with a creamy layer. One divides the quota among communities; the other would exclude better-off families.

Official sources

Related answers