The Signal 24हिंदी

Where do I find a judgment, and how do I read it?

Supreme Court judgments are on sci.gov.in; High Court and district court orders through eCourts services; free searchable copies on Indian Kanoon. Read the last part first: the operative order says what the court actually decided. In a bench with several opinions, check which view had the majority.

The hard truth

Most news coverage quotes observations, not holdings. An observation is what a judge said; a holding is what the court decided. Only the second binds anyone.

What the law actually says

Under Article 141 the law declared by the Supreme Court binds every court in India, and Article 144 requires all authorities to act in aid of the Supreme Court. What binds is the ratio decidendi, the principle the decision rests on; remarks made in passing, called obiter dicta, can persuade but do not bind. A decision of a larger bench prevails over a smaller one, so two judges cannot overrule a three-judge ruling. Supreme Court judgments since 2023 carry a neutral citation, such as 2023 INSC 1, alongside the case number; cite those, not a news report.

What you can do

  1. Search by case name and year, or by the parties.
  2. Read the operative order, then the headnote, then the reasoning.
  3. Note the bench size: a larger bench’s ruling overrides a smaller one’s.

Where people get caught out

  • Quoting the headnote. Headnotes are written by publishers, not judges; check the paragraph they summarise.
  • Reading one opinion in a split bench. Count the judges: in a 3:2 decision, the two dissenting opinions are not the law.
  • Missing what came later. A judgment may have been reviewed, overruled or referred to a larger bench; search for later cases that cite it.

Official sources

Related answers