The Signal 24हिंदी

Mandal waited a decade to be implemented. Rohini’s report has not even been published

India’s two most important commissions on backward classes share a history: governments that received their findings and then sat on them. Comfortably.

By · · 6 min read · source-linked

Primary source: Business Standard: The Mandal Commission decoded ()

Two commissions shaped how India thinks about Other Backward Classes. Both reported to governments that preferred not to act on them, at least not quickly.

Ten years in a drawer

For almost a decade after 1980, successive governments neither implemented the Mandal report nor rejected it. When it was finally acted upon, it was announced suddenly, without the public preparation that a change of that size needed, and the country paid for that in months of unrest.

What is the government waiting for?

The Rohini Commission was created to answer whether a handful of communities take most of the OBC quota’s benefits. That is an empirical question, and the commission was given years and public money to answer it. The answer exists. It sits with the government. In 2024 ThePrint described the report as in “cold storage”. Holding it back does not make the question go away. It just ensures that the debate goes on without the evidence.

What the two commissions were asked to do

The Second Backward Classes Commission was appointed in January 1979 under Article 340 and chaired by B.P. Mandal. It reported on 31 December 1980, identified 3,743 castes as backward, and recommended 27% reservation for them in central jobs. It relied on the 1931 census for population estimates, because no later caste count existed. The report was tabled and then left unimplemented until the V.P. Singh government’s announcement in August 1990.

The Rohini Commission was appointed under the same article in October 2017, to examine how the benefits of that 27% are shared among the more than 2,600 communities in the central OBC list, and to recommend sub-categories. In the decades between the two, no government built the data system that would have made either commission’s work quick or checkable. Both commissions were asked to answer questions with evidence the state had chosen not to collect.

Citations

  • Office Memorandum of 13 August 1990: reserved 27% of central government posts for Socially and Educationally Backward Classes on the Second Backward Classes (Mandal) Commission’s report of December 1980.
  • Indra Sawhney v Union of India, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217; AIR 1993 SC 477. Nine judges, decided 16 November 1992: upheld 27% OBC reservation, required the creamy layer to be excluded, and set the 50% rule. Document
  • Commission to examine sub-categorisation of OBCs (Justice G. Rohini), set up under Article 340 on 2 October 2017; report submitted to the President on 31 July 2023 after 14 extensions; not published.

Drafted with AI assistance from the cited public sources and translated into Hindi with AI assistance. Labelled source-linked: every claim is tied to a linked document, but this record has not yet been verified line by line by an editor. Corrections are logged in public.

Terms in this record

Reservation
A share of government jobs, seats in public educational institutions and seats in legislatures set aside for groups the Constitution allows the state to favour, chiefly Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Other Backward Classes and, since 2019, economically weaker sections. The power comes from Articles 15, 16, 330 and 332.
Other Backward Classes (OBC)
Socially and educationally backward classes other than Scheduled Castes and Tribes. There are two kinds of list: the Central List, used for central jobs and institutions, and each state’s own list, used for that state’s jobs and seats.
Creamy layer
The better-off section of OBC families, excluded from the OBC quota. The tests, set by the Department of Personnel and Training in office memorandum No. 36012/22/93-Estt.(SCT) of 8 September 1993, look at the parents’ posts and at income other than salary and farm income; the income limit has been ₹8 lakh a year since 1 September 2017.
The 50% ceiling
The rule from Indra Sawhney (1992) that reservation should not normally exceed half the seats or posts, save in extraordinary situations. The Supreme Court reaffirmed it unanimously when it struck down the Maratha quota in Jaishri Laxmanrao Patil on 5 May 2021; after Janhit Abhiyan (7 November 2022), the EWS quota sits outside it.
Indra Sawhney judgment (1992)
The nine-judge Supreme Court judgment of 16 November 1992 that upheld OBC reservation in central jobs after the Mandal Commission, required the creamy layer to be excluded, and set the 50% ceiling. It is still the starting point for almost every reservation case.
Mandal Commission
The Second Backward Classes Commission, chaired by B. P. Mandal, which reported in 1980 and recommended 27% reservation for OBCs in central jobs. The government implemented it by an office memorandum of 13 August 1990, and the Supreme Court upheld it in Indra Sawhney.
Rohini Commission
The commission set up under Article 340 on 2 October 2017, chaired by Justice G. Rohini, to examine sub-categorisation of the Central List of OBCs. It submitted its report to the President on 31 July 2023; the report has not been made public.
Sub-classification
Dividing a reserved category into groups so that a share of its quota goes to the less advantaged within it. In State of Punjab v Davinder Singh, decided on 1 August 2024, a seven-judge bench held 6:1 that states may sub-classify Scheduled Castes, overruling E. V. Chinnaiah (2005).

Answers on this

  • What was the Mandal Commission?

    The Second Backward Classes Commission, set up in 1979 under B.P. Mandal. It reported in December 1980, identified 3,743 castes as backward using eleven social, educational and economic indicators, estimated that OBCs made up about 52% of the population using 1931 census data, and recommended 27% reservation in central posts. A decade later the government implemented it by an office memorandum of 13 August 1990, and the Supreme Court upheld it in Indra Sawhney (1992).

  • Who decides which communities get reservation?

    Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe lists are notified by the President under Articles 341 and 342 and can be changed only by Parliament. The central OBC list is maintained by the Union government with the National Commission for Backward Classes. Since the 105th Amendment in 2021, states again keep their own backward-class lists. Central quotas are 15% for SC, 7.5% for ST, 27% for OBC and up to 10% for EWS; states set their own.

  • What is the Ninth Schedule, and does it protect a law from the courts?

    The Ninth Schedule was added by the First Amendment in 1951, together with Article 31B, which says that laws listed in it cannot be struck down for violating fundamental rights. Since I.R. Coelho (2007), laws added to it after 24 April 1973 can still be tested against the Constitution’s basic structure. Tamil Nadu’s 69% reservation law was placed in it by the 76th Amendment in 1994.

Keep reading