current · National
The 77th Amendment allowed reservation in promotions, on conditions the courts keep restating
After Indra Sawhney barred reservation in promotions, Parliament inserted Article 16(4A) in 1995. Courts have since required quantifiable data on inadequate representation, cadre by cadre.
- Authority
- Parliament of India
- Sector
- Public employment
- Before
- Indra Sawhney (1992) held that Article 16(4) did not permit reservation in promotions, prospectively after five years.
- After
- Article 16(4A) permits reservation in promotion for SCs and STs who are not adequately represented in the services, later extended to consequential seniority (85th Amendment, 2001).
- Legal basis
- Constitution (Seventy-seventh Amendment) Act, 1995
- In court
- Upheld in M. Nagaraj (2006) subject to quantifiable data; Jarnail Singh (2018) dropped the backwardness-data requirement for SCs and STs; Jarnail Singh (2022) required data cadre by cadre.
- Effective
- 17 June 1995
Why it matters
Parliament has repeatedly amended the Constitution to protect reservation in promotions for SCs and STs, and the Supreme Court has upheld those changes while insisting on data. That condition is where the policy keeps stalling: governments promote, or stop promoting, and then go to court without the cadre-wise figures the judgments require. The 2022 ruling made the unit of measurement the cadre, which means the data has to exist post by post, not department by department.
Questions still unanswered
- Which ministries have published cadre-wise representation data for SCs and STs?
- How many promotions are held up by pending litigation on this question?
- How often is the data reviewed, as the 2022 judgment requires?
Sources
- Constitution of India · Legislative Department, Government of India
- Jarnail Singh v. Lachhmi Narain Gupta, Civil Appeal No. 629 of 2022, judgment of 28 January 2022 · Supreme Court of India
- Reservation in promotion: the 6 issues settled by the Supreme Court on quantifiable data · SCC Online