The Signal 24हिंदी

Can reservation go above 50%?

Normally not. In Indra Sawhney (1992) the Supreme Court held that reservation should not exceed 50% except in extraordinary situations the state must prove. The 10% EWS quota sits outside that ceiling, the court held in 2022. Tamil Nadu’s 69% law is protected by being placed in the Ninth Schedule. Maharashtra’s 2018 Maratha quota and Bihar’s 2023 increase to 65% were struck down.

The hard truth

No state has won a case for crossing 50% by proving an extraordinary situation with published representation data. The route that has worked is political protection, not evidence.

What the law actually says

The ceiling is judge-made. In M R Balaji v State of Mysore (1962) the Supreme Court said reservation should generally stay below 50%, and in Indra Sawhney v Union of India (1992) a nine-judge bench fixed 50% as the rule, to be crossed only in extraordinary situations, such as far-flung and remote areas, and with extreme caution. In 2021 a five-judge bench struck down Maharashtra’s Maratha quota and declined to revisit that limit. In 2022, in Janhit Abhiyan, the court held that the 10% EWS quota does not breach the ceiling because it is a separate class. Laws placed in the Ninth Schedule, like Tamil Nadu’s 69% Act, are not beyond review: since I R Coelho (2007) they can be tested against the basic structure of the Constitution.

What you can do

  1. Read the state law and the judgment on it, not just the announcement.
  2. Ask what representation data the state published with the law.
  3. Check whether the law is in force, stayed, struck down or pending appeal before relying on it.

Where people get caught out

  • Counting EWS inside the 50%. Since 2022 it sits outside the ceiling, which is why central reservation adds up to 59.5%.
  • Thinking the Ninth Schedule makes a law untouchable. Since 2007, laws added to it after 24 April 1973 can still be tested against the basic structure.
  • Confusing a population share with a reason. Courts keep asking for evidence of backwardness and inadequate representation, not population figures alone.

Official sources

Related answers