The Signal 24हिंदी

What can the government refuse to tell me under RTI?

Section 8 of the RTI Act lists the exemptions: national security, information a court has forbidden, breach of legislative privilege, commercial confidence, information held in trust, information that would endanger someone or impede an investigation, Cabinet papers until a decision is taken, and personal information with no public interest. Even then, Section 8(2) allows disclosure when the public interest outweighs the harm.

The hard truth

“Fiduciary relationship” and “personal information” are the most stretched words in Indian administration. A refusal must name the specific exemption and explain it. A bare section number is grounds for appeal.

What the law actually says

A refusal must rest on the exemptions in Sections 8 and 9 of the RTI Act: information that would prejudice national security or a criminal investigation, Cabinet papers before a decision is taken, commercial confidence, or personal information with no relationship to any public activity or interest (Section 8(1)(j)), among others. Even then, Section 8(2) allows disclosure where the public interest outweighs the harm, and the proviso to Section 8(1) says information that cannot be denied to Parliament or a state legislature cannot be denied to a citizen. Section 10 requires the office to release the non-exempt part of a record, and Section 7(8) requires every refusal to give its reasons, the period for appeal and the appellate authority. Security and intelligence organisations in the Second Schedule are outside the Act, except for information about corruption and human rights violations (Section 24).

What you can do

  1. Read the refusal: does it name a clause of Section 8 and explain how it applies?
  2. If a decision has already been taken, Cabinet papers are disclosable under Section 8(1)(i). Say so.
  3. Argue public interest under Section 8(2) in your appeal.
  4. Ask for partial disclosure under Section 10: exempt parts can be removed and the rest released.

Where people get caught out

  • Accepting a refusal that only cites “Section 8”. Ask which clause and why it applies; a refusal without reasons is itself a ground for appeal.
  • Not asking for the rest of the file. If one page is exempt, Section 10 entitles you to the others with that part removed.
  • Treating “personal information” as the end of it. How an officer performed a public duty is not purely private; argue the public interest under Section 8(2).

Official sources

Related answers