The Signal 24हिंदी

Sit on the data, then say there is no data: how Indian governments dodge the reservation debate

Every government says reservation must be based on evidence. Every government has found a reason not to publish the evidence it already holds.

By The Signal 24 editorial board · · 5 min read · source-linked

Primary source: ThePrint: Rohini Commission report on OBC sub-categorisation in cold storage

India has a strange habit. It spends public money finding out who benefits from reservation, and then it hides the answer. It may be the only investigation in the country where the suspect gets to keep the evidence.

The 2011 caste census collected the data. In 2016 the government told a parliamentary committee that 98.87% of it was error-free. By 2021 the same data was, according to the government’s affidavit in the Supreme Court, unusable. Nobody outside government has been allowed to check which statement was true.

The Rohini Commission was set up in 2017 to find out whether a few communities capture most of the OBC quota. It was given 14 extensions and almost six years. It handed in its report on 31 July 2023. The public has not seen a page of it. Fourteen extensions is not a timeline. It is a lifestyle.

The OBC creamy-layer limit was fixed at ₹8 lakh in 2017 and was supposed to be reviewed. Parliament’s own committee says revision is the need of the hour. The ministry says there is no proposal. Prices have risen every year since; the ceiling has shown remarkable discipline.

A government that withholds the evidence cannot then ask to be trusted on the conclusion.

Every party, the same instinct

This is not one government’s failing. The Mandal report sat unimplemented through most of the 1980s, under governments of different parties. States across the political spectrum have passed quota laws they knew would collide with the 50% ceiling, without publishing the data that might have saved them. The instinct is bipartisan: keep the numbers private, keep the decision political.

What should happen now

  • Table the Rohini Commission report in Parliament, with its data, this session.
  • Release the SECC 2011 caste data with the government’s own error audit, so independent researchers can judge its quality.
  • Put income ceilings on a statutory review clock, with the inflation and income data behind each decision published.
  • Commit to a release date for Census 2027 caste tables before enumeration begins.

None of this requires anyone to win the argument about reservation. It only requires governments to stop pretending the argument can be settled without the facts they are sitting on.

Why withholding is a policy, not an accident

There is a pattern across governments of every party: commission a study, wait, receive it, and then sit on it. The pattern works because nothing forces publication. There is no rule that an Article 340 commission report must be tabled within a fixed time. There is no rule that a dataset collected with public money must be released with its error audit. There is no rule that an income ceiling must be reviewed on a schedule.

Each of those gaps can be closed by a single government order or a short amendment. That none has been closed tells you what the people in charge prefer.

Citations

  • Commission to examine sub-categorisation of OBCs (Justice G. Rohini), set up under Article 340 on 2 October 2017; report submitted to the President on 31 July 2023 after 14 extensions; not published.
  • Union of India’s affidavit in the Supreme Court, September 2021, in Maharashtra’s petition for SECC 2011 caste data: called the caste data unusable for official purposes. The court dismissed the petition on 15 December 2021.
  • Parliamentary Committee on the Welfare of Other Backward Classes, action-taken report tabled on 8 August 2025: called revising the creamy-layer income ceiling “the need of the hour”; the ministry said no proposal was under consideration.

Drafted with AI assistance from the cited public sources and translated into Hindi with AI assistance. Labelled source-linked: every claim is tied to a linked document, but this record has not yet been verified line by line by an editor. Corrections are logged in public.

Terms in this record

Reservation
A share of government jobs, seats in public educational institutions and seats in legislatures set aside for groups the Constitution allows the state to favour, chiefly Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Other Backward Classes and, since 2019, economically weaker sections. The power comes from Articles 15, 16, 330 and 332.
Other Backward Classes (OBC)
Socially and educationally backward classes other than Scheduled Castes and Tribes. There are two kinds of list: the Central List, used for central jobs and institutions, and each state’s own list, used for that state’s jobs and seats.
Creamy layer
The better-off section of OBC families, excluded from the OBC quota. The tests, set by the Department of Personnel and Training in office memorandum No. 36012/22/93-Estt.(SCT) of 8 September 1993, look at the parents’ posts and at income other than salary and farm income; the income limit has been ₹8 lakh a year since 1 September 2017.
The 50% ceiling
The rule from Indra Sawhney (1992) that reservation should not normally exceed half the seats or posts, save in extraordinary situations. The Supreme Court reaffirmed it unanimously when it struck down the Maratha quota in Jaishri Laxmanrao Patil on 5 May 2021; after Janhit Abhiyan (7 November 2022), the EWS quota sits outside it.
Mandal Commission
The Second Backward Classes Commission, chaired by B. P. Mandal, which reported in 1980 and recommended 27% reservation for OBCs in central jobs. The government implemented it by an office memorandum of 13 August 1990, and the Supreme Court upheld it in Indra Sawhney.
Rohini Commission
The commission set up under Article 340 on 2 October 2017, chaired by Justice G. Rohini, to examine sub-categorisation of the Central List of OBCs. It submitted its report to the President on 31 July 2023; the report has not been made public.
Sub-classification
Dividing a reserved category into groups so that a share of its quota goes to the less advantaged within it. In State of Punjab v Davinder Singh, decided on 1 August 2024, a seven-judge bench held 6:1 that states may sub-classify Scheduled Castes, overruling E. V. Chinnaiah (2005).
Right to Information (RTI)
The right, under the Right to Information Act, 2005, to ask a public authority for information it holds. It must normally reply within 30 days, and can refuse only on the grounds the Act lists.

Answers on this

  • How do I file an RTI application?

    Write to the Public Information Officer of the office that holds the information. For central government bodies you can file online at rtionline.gov.in with a ₹10 fee; states set their own fees and portals. Applicants below the poverty line pay no fee, and you never have to say why you want the information.

  • I faced caste discrimination. Where can I go?

    For atrocities against Scheduled Castes and Tribes, file an FIR under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989; police must register it. You can also complain to the National Commission for Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes, and OBC members to the National Commission for Backward Classes. On campus, the anti-discrimination mechanism under the UGC’s 2012 regulations is the current route. Free legal aid is available from your District Legal Services Authority.

  • How do I get free legal aid?

    Under the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, members of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, women, children, persons with disabilities, victims of trafficking or of disasters and caste atrocities, industrial workers, people in custody, and people whose income is below the limit set by their state are entitled to free legal services, including a lawyer and court fees. Apply to your District Legal Services Authority, the taluka legal services committee, or call the national legal aid helpline 15100.

Keep reading