One number, two very different tests: how ₹8 lakh came to decide both OBC and EWS eligibility
The OBC creamy-layer limit has been ₹8 lakh since 2017. The EWS limit has been ₹8 lakh since 2019. They measure different things, and neither has been revised. Inflation did not get the memo.
Primary source: DoPT Office Memorandum No. 36033/1/2013-Estt.(Res), 13 September 2017 (copy on the National Commission for Backward Classes website) ()
The figure of ₹8 lakh a year now decides eligibility for two separate reservation systems. The coincidence has been convenient for governments and confusing for applicants.
How the EWS line was defended
When the Supreme Court questioned the basis for the EWS limit during the NEET-PG counselling dispute in 2021, the Centre set up a three-member committee. Its report, dated 31 December 2021, concluded that ₹8 lakh struck a “fine balance” and argued that it was not mechanically borrowed from the OBC limit, because the two tests count income differently. In January 2022 the Centre told the court it would keep the limit.
How many families does the line actually cover?
We could not find any official estimate published by the government of how many families fall under the EWS threshold, or how many OBC families are excluded by the creamy-layer test. Without those numbers, no one outside government can say whether either line is too high, too low, or doing what it was meant to do.
The frozen OBC limit
The creamy-layer limit was meant to be reviewed periodically. In August 2025, Parliament’s committee on OBC welfare called its revision the “need of the hour”. The Ministry of Social Justice told the committee there was no proposal under consideration. Eight years of inflation have passed with the limit unchanged. In real terms, every year of inaction tightens the test.
How the same number came to mean two things
The OBC creamy-layer limit was raised to ₹8 lakh in 2017. When the EWS quota arrived in 2019, the government used the same ₹8 lakh as its income ceiling. When the EWS criteria were challenged, the Centre set up a committee chaired by former Finance Secretary Ajay Bhushan Pandey, which recommended keeping the ₹8 lakh line; the Centre told the Supreme Court in January 2022 that it would do so. The two tests still count income differently: the OBC test excludes salary and agricultural income and looks across three years, while the EWS test counts family income from all sources in the previous year and adds asset exclusions.
So two families can meet one test and fail the other with identical earnings. The figure is the same; the rules underneath it are not; and neither has been formally revised against inflation in years.
Citations
- DoPT Office Memorandum No. 36012/22/93-Estt.(SCT), 8 September 1993: set the creamy-layer tests (the Schedule of exclusions) for central posts.
- DoPT Office Memorandum No. 36033/1/2013-Estt.(Res), 13 September 2017: raised the creamy-layer income limit from ₹6 lakh to ₹8 lakh a year, with effect from 1 September 2017. Document
- DoPT Office Memorandum No. 36039/1/2019-Estt.(Res), 31 January 2019: EWS criteria and certificate format for central posts, for direct-recruitment vacancies notified on or after 1 February 2019.
- Report of the committee on EWS criteria (Ajay Bhushan Pandey, V. K. Malhotra, Sanjeev Sanyal), 31 December 2021, filed with the Supreme Court the same day: recommended keeping the ₹8 lakh family-income limit.
- Parliamentary Committee on the Welfare of Other Backward Classes, action-taken report tabled on 8 August 2025: called revising the creamy-layer income ceiling “the need of the hour”; the ministry said no proposal was under consideration.
Drafted with AI assistance from the cited public sources and translated into Hindi with AI assistance. Labelled source-linked: every claim is tied to a linked document, but this record has not yet been verified line by line by an editor. Corrections are logged in public.