The Signal 24हिंदी

current · National

States may sub-classify Scheduled Castes and Tribes, a seven-judge bench holds

In State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh, the Supreme Court held 6:1 that states can reserve a share within the SC and ST quota for the least-represented groups, on the basis of data.

Authority
Supreme Court of India (Constitution Bench)
Sector
Education and public employment
Before
E.V. Chinnaiah v. State of Andhra Pradesh (2004): the SC list was a single homogeneous class and could not be divided.
After
States may sub-classify SCs and STs, based on quantifiable data on inadequate representation. Four judges said a creamy-layer exclusion should be evolved; the Union Cabinet said on 9 August 2024 there was no such provision.
Legal basis
State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh, decided 1 August 2024
In court
Binding Constitution Bench judgment. Implementation is state by state.
Effective
1 August 2024

Why it matters

For twenty years E.V. Chinnaiah treated the Scheduled Castes of a state as one class, so the communities that benefited least from the quota had no legal way to get a share of it. Davinder Singh changed that, but it gave states a power, not a duty, and it tied that power to data on representation that most states have not published. The judgment also opened an argument about a creamy layer for SCs and STs, which the Union Cabinet rejected within days.

Questions still unanswered

  • Which states have published the representation data a sub-classification law would need?
  • How will a state show that a sub-group is inadequately represented, cadre by cadre?
  • If the creamy-layer remarks are not binding, what guidance will courts follow when the first sub-classification law is challenged?

Sources