69% protected by the Ninth Schedule
Tamil Nadu
Where India’s first reservation case began, and where the one quota above 50% that has lasted is shielded by Parliament, not proof.
The record
- 1921-09-16 — Madras Presidency issues its first communal order on representation in public services.
- 1951-04-09 — Supreme Court strikes down the Madras communal admissions order (Champakam Dorairajan).
- 1951-06-18 — The First Amendment inserts Article 15(4) in response.
- 1994-08-31 — The 76th Amendment places the state’s 69% reservation law in the Ninth Schedule.
- 2026-10-29 — The Cabinet approved forming a Social Justice Commission to conduct a survey; the commission and survey were not yet reported as operational. (Secondary report: The Hindu)
Questions for the state
- Why has the challenge to the 69% law stayed undecided for so long?
Records
States / Paper note
Bihar counted its castes, raised the quota to 65%, and lost in the High Court within seven months
It did what the Centre would not: it published a caste count. Then it wrote a law the Patna High Court found had skipped the part where you show the courts why the count justifies breaching the ceiling.
History / Archive
Fifteen months in: how a Madras admissions case forced the Constitution’s first rewrite
In April 1951 the Supreme Court struck down Madras’s communal admissions order. By June, Parliament had amended the Constitution. It remains the fastest the Republic has ever moved on reservation.
Courts & Policy / Paper note
Indra Sawhney, 1992: the 50% ceiling, the creamy layer, and a promise on promotions that Parliament reversed
A nine-judge bench upheld the OBC quota but attached conditions. Governments have spent three decades amending around them, with impressive stamina.
States / Explainer
Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, Bihar: three states, three quota laws, one ceiling they all knew about
States keep passing reservation laws that breach the 50% limit, in election seasons, without the evidence the Supreme Court has said they need. Then the courts strike them down, and the cycle resets in time for the next election.