Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, Bihar: three states, three quota laws, one ceiling they all knew about
States keep passing reservation laws that breach the 50% limit, in election seasons, without the evidence the Supreme Court has said they need. Then the courts strike them down, and the cycle resets in time for the next election.
Primary source: Bar & Bench: Supreme Court refuses to stay Patna High Court decision quashing Bihar reservation law ()
Every state sets its own reservation levels for its own jobs and colleges. Every state also knows the rule the Supreme Court set in 1992: no more than 50%, except in extraordinary situations backed by evidence. What happens next depends on whether a government treats that rule as a legal standard or a political obstacle.
The pattern
Did any of these governments not know about the 50% rule?
No. The ceiling has been settled law for three decades. A state that wants to exceed it has to show the court an extraordinary situation, with data. Maharashtra’s 2018 law relied on a backward class commission whose conclusions the Supreme Court called unsustainable. Bihar’s increase came weeks after a survey and was struck down within months.
When a law fails this way, the people who relied on it pay the price: admissions are thrown into doubt, recruitment processes stall, and candidates end up in court for years. The politicians who announced the quota have usually already collected the credit.
What a serious state would do
Publish the full data behind any proposal to cross 50%, before the vote. Have it examined by a commission whose report is made public in full. If a government believes the ceiling itself is wrong, it can argue that openly, in Parliament and in court, rather than legislating around it and leaving citizens to absorb the fallout.
What separates the law that survived from the laws that fell
Tamil Nadu’s 69% has lasted three decades not because it proved an extraordinary situation in court, but because it was placed in the Ninth Schedule by the 76th Amendment in 1994, with Parliament’s support. Challenges to it have remained pending in the Supreme Court for years. Maharashtra and Bihar tried to win on evidence in the ordinary courts and lost, each time because the evidence on representation in public services was missing or found insufficient.
There is a lesson here that no government likes: the route that has worked is political protection, not proof. A state that wanted to win on the merits would need to publish the representation data first and legislate second. None has.
Citations
- Gaurav Kumar v State of Bihar, Patna High Court, CWJC No. 16760 of 2023; 2024 SCC OnLine Pat 2308. Decided 20 June 2024: struck down the Bihar reservation amendment Acts of 2023 that raised the quota to 65%. Document
- Supreme Court order of 29 July 2024 in the State of Bihar’s appeals: refused to stay the Patna High Court judgment and listed the appeals for hearing.
- Maharashtra State Reservation for Socially and Educationally Backward Classes Act, 2024 (Maharashtra Act No. XVI of 2024): passed on 20 February 2024; Governor’s assent and publication in the Maharashtra Government Gazette on 26 February 2024, the day it came into force. Document
- Jaishri Laxmanrao Patil v Chief Minister, Maharashtra, [2021] 15 SCR 715. Five judges, decided 5 May 2021: struck down the Maharashtra SEBC Act, 2018 and declined to revisit the 50% rule.
- I. R. Coelho v State of Tamil Nadu, (2007) 2 SCC 1. Nine judges, decided 11 January 2007: laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 can be tested against the basic structure. Document
- Indra Sawhney v Union of India, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217; AIR 1993 SC 477. Nine judges, decided 16 November 1992: upheld 27% OBC reservation, required the creamy layer to be excluded, and set the 50% rule. Document
Drafted with AI assistance from the cited public sources and translated into Hindi with AI assistance. Labelled source-linked: every claim is tied to a linked document, but this record has not yet been verified line by line by an editor. Corrections are logged in public.