Topic file
Courts & Policy
Judgments, amendments and office memoranda, read in full rather than in press-release summary. We separate what a court held from what a judge observed, and an interim order from a final one.
The law gets made twice: once by government, once by the court cleaning up.
The state of play
- 2026-01-29 — UGC equity regulations stayed as prima facie vague; the 2012 rules continue under Article 142.
- 2024-08-01 — Seven judges allow sub-classification of SCs and STs, 6:1, on the basis of data.
- 2022-11-07 — The 10% EWS quota is upheld 3:2 in Janhit Abhiyan.
- 1992-11-16 — Indra Sawhney sets the 50% ceiling and the creamy-layer exclusion.
Questions still unanswered
- Does the four-judge creamy-layer observation in Davinder Singh bind governments?
- Which states have collected the cadre-wise data that promotion quotas require?
Records
Courts & Policy / Explainer
What the Constitution actually says about reservation, article by article
Most of the reservation framework was not in the original 1950 text. It was added amendment by amendment, usually within months of a court ruling the government did not like. Drafting first, reading later.
Courts & Policy / Paper note
Indra Sawhney, 1992: the 50% ceiling, the creamy layer, and a promise on promotions that Parliament reversed
A nine-judge bench upheld the OBC quota but attached conditions. Governments have spent three decades amending around them, with impressive stamina.
Courts & Policy / Explainer
Sixteen years of the same court order: count the cadre before you reserve the promotion
Since 2006 the Supreme Court has told governments that reservation in promotions needs quantifiable data on representation. In 2022 it had to spell out, again, that the count must be done cadre by cadre. Some lessons need a third judgment.
Courts & Policy / Explainer
The court allowed states to divide the SC quota. Within nine days, the Union Cabinet ruled out the creamy layer
A seven-judge bench said sub-classification is constitutional, and four judges said states should exclude a creamy layer. The Centre answered the second point at a press briefing. Parliament was presumably busy.
Courts & Policy / Paper note
The EWS quota passed Parliament in two days and survived the Supreme Court by one vote
The 103rd Amendment was introduced and passed within days in January 2019. In November 2022 a five-judge bench upheld it 3:2, and the dissent asked a question the government has never answered with data.