Sixteen years of the same court order: count the cadre before you reserve the promotion
Since 2006 the Supreme Court has told governments that reservation in promotions needs quantifiable data on representation. In 2022 it had to spell out, again, that the count must be done cadre by cadre. Some lessons need a third judgment.
Primary source: Supreme Court of India: Jarnail Singh v. Lachhmi Narain Gupta, Civil Appeal No. 629 of 2022, judgment of 28 January 2022 ()
Reservation in promotions for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes is constitutional. Whether a particular government is entitled to apply it depends on one thing: whether it has done the counting the courts have demanded for almost two decades.
What the 2022 judgment settled
The court said the unit for collecting data is the cadre. A state cannot show that SCs are adequately or inadequately represented across a whole department and use that to reserve promotions in a particular grade. The court declined to set a yardstick for what counts as inadequate. It left that to governments, along with the period for review, on condition that both be reasonable.
Why did it take three judgments to say this?
Because governments kept arguing for less. One state collected data by groups of posts; the court called that approach bad in law. The cost of this litigation has fallen on employees, whose promotions and seniority were stalled for years while governments defended data they had not properly collected.
What to ask your government
- Has it published cadre-wise data on SC and ST representation for the posts where it reserves promotions?
- When was that data last reviewed, and by whom?
- What benchmark did it use to call representation inadequate?
If the answers are not public, the promotion policy is resting on an assumption, not on the record the Supreme Court requires.
Why the data keeps not arriving
Collecting cadre-wise representation data is not technically hard. Every government department already maintains rosters for each cadre, because reservation in direct recruitment is administered post by post. The information exists in files. What is missing is an obligation to compile it, check it, and publish it in a form a court or a citizen can read.
The result is a cycle. A government extends reservation in promotions; a court asks for the data; the government promises to collect it; the matter returns to court. The 2022 judgment in Jarnail Singh made the unit of analysis the cadre, which makes the task more specific, not easier to avoid.
Citations
- M. Nagaraj v Union of India, (2006) 8 SCC 212. Five judges, decided 19 October 2006: upheld reservation in promotion subject to data on backwardness, inadequate representation and efficiency.
- Jarnail Singh v Lachhmi Narain Gupta, (2018) 10 SCC 396. Five judges, 2018: dropped the requirement of data on the backwardness of SCs and STs; the data on inadequate representation stays.
- Jarnail Singh v Lachhmi Narain Gupta, Civil Appeal No. 629 of 2022 (from SLP (C) No. 30621 of 2011), decided 28 January 2022 by Justices L. Nageswara Rao, Sanjiv Khanna and B. R. Gavai: data must be collected cadre by cadre; the court declined to set a yardstick for adequacy. Document
Drafted with AI assistance from the cited public sources and translated into Hindi with AI assistance. Labelled source-linked: every claim is tied to a linked document, but this record has not yet been verified line by line by an editor. Corrections are logged in public.