The Signal 24हिंदी

Stop passing quota laws designed to lose in court

State governments keep announcing reservations they know will breach the 50% ceiling. The applause comes in the election season; the bill comes due for students and job-seekers.

By The Signal 24 editorial board · · 5 min read · source-linked

Primary source: Bar & Bench: Supreme Court strikes down Maratha reservation law, upholds 50% cap ()

In 2018 Maharashtra gave Marathas 16% reservation. In May 2021 the Supreme Court struck it down because the state had not shown the extraordinary situation needed to cross 50%. In February 2024 Maharashtra passed a new law giving Marathas 10%, and that law is now being challenged in the Bombay High Court.

In November 2023 Bihar raised its reservation from 50% to 65%, weeks after publishing its caste survey. In June 2024 the Patna High Court struck the increase down. In July 2024 the Supreme Court refused to stay that ruling.

These governments did not stumble into the 50% rule. It has been the law since 1992. It is old enough to contest an assembly election itself. They passed these laws anyway.

A quota that a government knows will not survive is not a policy. It is an announcement.

Who pays

Not the ministers who announced the quotas. They collected their applause when the bills passed and were rarely in the courtroom when the bills died. The cost falls on the people the laws claimed to help, and on everyone else in the same queue: admissions held subject to court orders, recruitment frozen, merit lists redrawn, years of litigation. Families plan around a reservation that may not exist by the time the results are declared.

What a serious government would do

If a state believes its situation is extraordinary, it should prove it in public before the vote. That means a backward classes commission with real independence, a full published report, and the underlying data available for scrutiny. If the evidence is strong, it will stand a better chance in court. If it is weak, the state will have learnt that before it raised expectations it could not meet.

If a government believes the 50% ceiling itself is wrong, it should say so plainly and make that case in Parliament and before the Supreme Court. What it should not do is keep legislating around the ceiling and leaving citizens to carry the cost when the courts apply it.

Who pays when a quota law falls

When a quota law is struck down, the legislators who passed it have already collected the credit. The cost falls on students who enrolled and job applicants who were appointed under rules that later collapsed, on the candidates displaced in the meantime, and on public trust in the idea that a law means what it says. Courts often protect admissions and appointments already made, but uncertainty in the years in between is its own harm.

A government that means it would do the slow part first: publish representation data, cadre by cadre; commission a study that answers the legal test the courts have set; and only then legislate. That sequence is not a secret. It is in every judgment that has struck one of these laws down.

Citations

  • Jaishri Laxmanrao Patil v Chief Minister, Maharashtra, [2021] 15 SCR 715. Five judges, decided 5 May 2021: struck down the Maharashtra SEBC Act, 2018 and declined to revisit the 50% rule.
  • Gaurav Kumar v State of Bihar, Patna High Court, CWJC No. 16760 of 2023; 2024 SCC OnLine Pat 2308. Decided 20 June 2024: struck down the Bihar reservation amendment Acts of 2023 that raised the quota to 65%. Document
  • Indra Sawhney v Union of India, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217; AIR 1993 SC 477. Nine judges, decided 16 November 1992: upheld 27% OBC reservation, required the creamy layer to be excluded, and set the 50% rule. Document

Drafted with AI assistance from the cited public sources and translated into Hindi with AI assistance. Labelled source-linked: every claim is tied to a linked document, but this record has not yet been verified line by line by an editor. Corrections are logged in public.

Terms in this record

Reservation
A share of government jobs, seats in public educational institutions and seats in legislatures set aside for groups the Constitution allows the state to favour, chiefly Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Other Backward Classes and, since 2019, economically weaker sections. The power comes from Articles 15, 16, 330 and 332.
Other Backward Classes (OBC)
Socially and educationally backward classes other than Scheduled Castes and Tribes. There are two kinds of list: the Central List, used for central jobs and institutions, and each state’s own list, used for that state’s jobs and seats.
Creamy layer
The better-off section of OBC families, excluded from the OBC quota. The tests, set by the Department of Personnel and Training in office memorandum No. 36012/22/93-Estt.(SCT) of 8 September 1993, look at the parents’ posts and at income other than salary and farm income; the income limit has been ₹8 lakh a year since 1 September 2017.
The 50% ceiling
The rule from Indra Sawhney (1992) that reservation should not normally exceed half the seats or posts, save in extraordinary situations. The Supreme Court reaffirmed it unanimously when it struck down the Maratha quota in Jaishri Laxmanrao Patil on 5 May 2021; after Janhit Abhiyan (7 November 2022), the EWS quota sits outside it.
Indra Sawhney judgment (1992)
The nine-judge Supreme Court judgment of 16 November 1992 that upheld OBC reservation in central jobs after the Mandal Commission, required the creamy layer to be excluded, and set the 50% ceiling. It is still the starting point for almost every reservation case.
Struck down
Declared unconstitutional or invalid by a court in its final decision, so that the law or rule has no effect. Only a later judgment or a new law can change that.
Right to Information (RTI)
The right, under the Right to Information Act, 2005, to ask a public authority for information it holds. It must normally reply within 30 days, and can refuse only on the grounds the Act lists.
Act of Parliament
A law passed by both Houses of Parliament and assented to by the President. Acts can be read in full on India Code; many take effect only when the government notifies a start date.

Answers on this

  • Can reservation go above 50%?

    Normally not. In Indra Sawhney (1992) the Supreme Court held that reservation should not exceed 50% except in extraordinary situations the state must prove. The 10% EWS quota sits outside that ceiling, the court held in 2022. Tamil Nadu’s 69% law is protected by being placed in the Ninth Schedule. Maharashtra’s 2018 Maratha quota and Bihar’s 2023 increase to 65% were struck down.

  • What is the Ninth Schedule, and does it protect a law from the courts?

    The Ninth Schedule was added by the First Amendment in 1951, together with Article 31B, which says that laws listed in it cannot be struck down for violating fundamental rights. Since I.R. Coelho (2007), laws added to it after 24 April 1973 can still be tested against the Constitution’s basic structure. Tamil Nadu’s 69% reservation law was placed in it by the 76th Amendment in 1994.

  • Is my caste certificate valid in another state?

    For Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, reservation is tied to the state where your community is listed. If you move, you generally cannot claim reservation in your new state’s jobs or seats, though you keep it in your state of origin and for central government posts. The Supreme Court settled this in Marri Chandra Shekhar Rao (1990), and a Constitution Bench reaffirmed it in Bir Singh (2018). OBC lists differ from state to state; central posts use the Central List.

Keep reading