Topic file
States
States legislate reservation in election season and defend it in court in the off-season. We track each law from bill to judgment, and ask the question courts ask first: where is the representation data?
One Constitution, many quota laws, and one ceiling they all knew about.
The state of play
- 2024-06-20 — Patna High Court strikes down Bihar’s 65% law. The Supreme Court refused a stay; appeal pending.
- 2024-02-20 — Maharashtra passes its third Maratha quota law (10%). Challenge before a Bombay High Court full bench.
- 2021-05-05 — The Supreme Court strikes down Maharashtra’s 2018 Maratha quota for breaching the ceiling.
Questions still unanswered
- Will Bihar publish representation data, not just population data, in its appeal?
- Does the Shukre Commission report show the extraordinary situation the 2021 judgment required?
Records
States / Paper note
Bihar counted its castes, raised the quota to 65%, and lost in the High Court within seven months
It did what the Centre would not: it published a caste count. Then it wrote a law the Patna High Court found had skipped the part where you show the courts why the count justifies breaching the ceiling.
States / Article
Three Maratha quota laws in ten years, and the third one’s court hearing keeps starting over
Maharashtra has legislated a Maratha quota in 2014, 2018 and 2024. Two died in court. The third has spent more time waiting for a bench than being argued before one.
States / Explainer
Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, Bihar: three states, three quota laws, one ceiling they all knew about
States keep passing reservation laws that breach the 50% limit, in election seasons, without the evidence the Supreme Court has said they need. Then the courts strike them down, and the cycle resets in time for the next election.
States / Opinion
Stop passing quota laws designed to lose in court
State governments keep announcing reservations they know will breach the 50% ceiling. The applause comes in the election season; the bill comes due for students and job-seekers.