10% Maratha quota under challenge
Maharashtra
Two earlier laws were struck down; the 2024 10% law is now back before the Bombay High Court, while representation data remains unpublished.
The record
- 1902-07-26 — In princely Kolhapur, now in Maharashtra, an order reserves half of state posts for backward classes.
- 2021-05-05 — Supreme Court strikes down the 2018 SEBC Act for breaching the 50% ceiling.
- 2024-02-20 — SEBC Act, 2024 grants Marathas 10% on the Shukre Commission’s report.
- 2026-10-09 — The Bombay High Court resumed hearings on petitions challenging the 2024 law’s 10% Maratha reservation; no final ruling was reported. (Secondary report: Free Press Journal)
Questions for the state
- What did the Shukre Commission find that the Gaikwad Commission did not, and where is its data?
- What happens to candidates admitted under the 2024 Act if it falls?
Records
Data & Notes / Explainer
India will count caste for the first time since 1931. Here is what to check before you believe the tables
The enumeration is coming in February 2027. The classification codes, the release timetable and access to the raw data have not been published. Those three things decide whether the count settles anything.
States / Article
Three Maratha quota laws in ten years, and the third one’s court hearing keeps starting over
Maharashtra has legislated a Maratha quota in 2014, 2018 and 2024. Two died in court. The third has spent more time waiting for a bench than being argued before one.
Latest / Explainer
Reservation in India: what the law allows, what the courts capped, and what the state won’t publish
Seventy-five years of constitutional amendments and court rulings have built the system. The data that would show whether it works is still being withheld, presumably for its own protection.
Courts & Policy / Explainer
What the Constitution actually says about reservation, article by article
Most of the reservation framework was not in the original 1950 text. It was added amendment by amendment, usually within months of a court ruling the government did not like. Drafting first, reading later.
History / Explainer
Before 1950: a princely order in Kolhapur, a pact in a Poona jail, and the seats that came out of it
Reservation did not begin with the Constitution. It began with administrators and reformers who decided that a closed bureaucracy was a political problem.
Courts & Policy / Paper note
Indra Sawhney, 1992: the 50% ceiling, the creamy layer, and a promise on promotions that Parliament reversed
A nine-judge bench upheld the OBC quota but attached conditions. Governments have spent three decades amending around them, with impressive stamina.
States / Explainer
Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, Bihar: three states, three quota laws, one ceiling they all knew about
States keep passing reservation laws that breach the 50% limit, in election seasons, without the evidence the Supreme Court has said they need. Then the courts strike them down, and the cycle resets in time for the next election.
Data & Notes / Explainer
Collected, then called unusable: the caste data India paid for and never saw
The last full caste count in a census was in 1931. The 2011 caste data was gathered and then buried. Census 2027 promises a count, and the notification that launched it forgot to mention caste. Easy mistake.
Latest / Opinion
Sit on the data, then say there is no data: how Indian governments dodge the reservation debate
Every government says reservation must be based on evidence. Every government has found a reason not to publish the evidence it already holds.
States / Opinion
Stop passing quota laws designed to lose in court
State governments keep announcing reservations they know will breach the 50% ceiling. The applause comes in the election season; the bill comes due for students and job-seekers.